Company Values vs. Culture: What Actually Drives Behavior
Are you relying on your company values to define your culture, instead of paying attention to the behaviors that actually shape it? Then this episode is for you. Andrea and Michelle unpack one of the most common leadership disconnects: assuming that what’s written on the wall reflects what’s happening in real life.
They challenge the idea that values and culture are the same, showing how culture is really built through what leaders reward, tolerate, and excuse every day. You’ll hear why even well-intended values can become meaningless or even weaponized when they are not clearly defined through behavior, and how inconsistency across leaders quietly creates confusion, misalignment, and frustration across teams.
Andrea and Michelle also dig into the subtle patterns that reinforce culture over time, like avoiding hard conversations, allowing high performers to bypass expectations, or stepping in to solve problems instead of developing people. These repeated moments shape the real standards of your organization, whether you realize it or not.
This episode offers practical ways to shift your focus from aspirational values to observable standards, helping you clarify expectations, align leadership behavior, and build a culture that actually drives performance. If you want your culture to be more than just words, this conversation will show you where to start.
LISTEN TO THE EPISODE
Expand Your Leadership Skills.
Company Values vs. Culture: What Actually Drives Behavior
Most organizations believe they have a strong workplace culture. They point to their values, reference them in meetings, and display them on walls, websites, and onboarding materials. But when you look closer, there’s often a disconnect between what’s written and how people actually behave. The difference between company values vs. culture is not subtle. It’s foundational to how organizations function.
At Revela, we believe organizational culture is not defined by what you say. It’s defined by what you consistently reinforce through leadership behavior. On this episode of The Leadership Hustle, Andrea Fredrickson and Michelle Hill explored the gap between values and reality, why leadership accountability determines culture, and how workplace standards (not words) shape employee behavior.
What Workplace Culture Really Is
Fredrickson defined it directly when she stated, “Culture is the standards that you reward, allow, tolerate, and excuse.” This means culture is not what’s written, but what’s reinforced. Every organization has a culture, whether it’s intentional or not. That culture is shaped daily by:
Leadership behavior
Workplace standards
What gets addressed and what doesn’t
What is rewarded and what is ignored
Culture is a byproduct of leadership accountability. It’s the result of what leaders do and don’t do consistently.
This is why two organizations with the same stated values can have completely different cultures. The difference is in what leaders consistently reinforce. Over time, employees learn what actually matters by watching how decisions are made, how conflict is handled, and what behaviors are rewarded. Culture becomes predictable, not because it’s documented, but because it’s demonstrated repeatedly.
Why Company Values Often Fall Flat
Values are not inherently bad. They provide direction, create a shared language, and define what an organization aspires to become. As Hill explained, they are often aspirational, “...setting some framework for what they want it [the company culture] to be.”
The problem is that values are often disconnected from behavior. Take a common value like accountability. Without clear workplace standards, accountability can mean different things to different people: meeting deadlines, owning mistakes, or simply responding to emails. That lack of clarity leads to inconsistency.
In some cases, values aren’t just unclear, they’re misused. Fredrickson described how organizations sometimes “weaponize” values, using them as a tool for discipline while failing to hold leaders to the same standard. When that happens, employees don’t reject the value. They reject the inconsistency. What remains isn’t the stated value. It’s the behavior leaders allow.
Leadership Behavior Defines Organizational Culture
The most important factor when comparing company values vs. culture is leadership behavior. Leaders can’t just communicate expectations. They need to demonstrate them.
Fredrickson posed the question: “If I were to follow you for a week, what would your behavior tell me your standards are?” That question cuts through everything, because employees don’t follow what leaders say. They follow what leaders do. If leaders show up late, avoid difficult conversations, excuse high performers, and delay accountability, those behaviors become normalized. They become the culture.
This is where workplace standards come into play. If values are aspirational and culture is behavioral, standards define what behavior actually looks like. They create clarity around expectations that would otherwise be left up to interpretation. To make standards clear, leaders should ask:
What does “on time” actually mean?
How quickly are issues addressed?
How are disagreements handled?
What level of follow-through is expected?
Without clear standards, values remain vague. With standards, expectations become measurable, consistent, and repeatable. This is what turns leadership development from theory into practice, and what ultimately shapes organizational culture.
The Impact of Tolerated Behavior
One of the most important truths about organizational culture is that it is shaped more by what leaders tolerate than what they promote. Fredrickson explained this through a simple example: If a leader ignores behavior once, it’s an exception. If they ignore it repeatedly, it becomes the standard.
This is how culture shifts. Not through major events, but through small, repeated decisions. Hill reinforced this idea, stating, “It’s never a big event…it’s always that little repetitive pattern.” Over time, those patterns become the culture.
When Leadership Inconsistency Breaks Culture
One of the fastest ways to weaken workplace culture is inconsistency across leaders. When leadership teams are not aligned, standards become situational. One leader enforces accountability, another avoids confrontation, and another makes exceptions. The result is confusion and eventually, disengagement.
Hill noted that this creates an “us versus them” dynamic across teams. Employees begin adjusting behavior depending on who they’re dealing with instead of following a consistent standard. This issue becomes even more visible when high performers are treated differently.
In many organizations, a top performer is allowed to communicate poorly, ignore expectations, or shift work onto others because of their results. That exception doesn’t stay isolated and resets the standard for everyone. Once behavior is tolerated for one person, it becomes acceptable for others.
Culture Shows Up Under Pressure
One of the clearest indicators of organizational culture is how leaders behave under pressure. When things are calm, it’s easy to uphold standards and communicate clearly. But when deadlines tighten and stress increases, true behavior emerges.
In those moments, leaders reveal whether they will stay consistent and reinforce expectations or react emotionally and lower standards. They either communicate clearly and hold accountability, or avoid difficult conversations altogether. These decisions happen quickly, but their impact is lasting. Those high-pressure moments define culture far more than anything written in a handbook.
Building Culture Through Leadership Accountability
If culture is shaped by behavior, improving it requires intentional leadership accountability. Fredrickson outlined a practical approach: define clear workplace standards, align leadership teams around them, and determine what happens when they are not met. This also includes holding leaders accountable to each other. Without alignment, standards quickly become inconsistent.
As Fredrickson challenged, “What are we as leaders going to do if we notice each other violating them?” That level of accountability may feel uncomfortable, but it is necessary for consistency. When leaders hold each other accountable, standards become real instead of optional. Without it, culture becomes fragmented.
Aligning Values and Culture the Right Way
Values and culture are not opposing ideas. They serve different purposes. Values define intention, standards define behavior, and culture reflects reality. The key is aligning all three in a way that is practical and consistent. Without alignment, values stay theoretical.
Fredrickson stressed that alignment should come after expectations are clearly defined. Starting with behavior prevents important standards from being overlooked. It also keeps culture grounded in what actually happens, not what’s intended.
Culture Starts and Stops With Leadership
The difference between company values vs. culture is simple: values describe intention, but culture reflects reality. What leaders tolerate and reinforce becomes the standard. Closing that gap requires focusing on behavior, not just messaging. At Revela, we believe organizational culture improves when leaders consistently define, demonstrate, and uphold clear workplace standards. To explore more insights on leadership behavior, leadership development, and building stronger workplace culture, listen to the rest of The Leadership Hustle podcast!
About the Hosts
Andrea Fredrickson
Andrea Fredrickson is a thought leader and consultant at Revela, an organization based in Omaha, Nebraska specializing in the development of leaders, culture alignment, and business strategy for private and family businesses of all sizes. Revela is one of the region's most experienced thought challengers, helping individuals and companies find their greatness. Andrea has built an amazing team by believing that fundamentally people want to be successful and become better versions of themselves.
-
Andrea has degrees in education, management, and business. She is the author of Insight Unseen; How to lead with 20/20 business vision. She helps people see things differently, self-reflect, and never stop looking for ways to improve themselves on a personal and professional level. Andrea has spent more than 30 years researching and developing methods to help people communicate and lead more effectively.
When Andrea isn’t working with clients, you’ll find her spending time with her family & friends and making memories by exploring new cities.
Michelle Hill
Michelle Hill is a master facilitator and coach at Revela, an organization specializing in the development of leaders and aligning the culture of privately held and family businesses of all sizes. Revela is one of the region's most experienced thought challengers, helping individuals and companies find their greatness.
-
An ambitious leader, Michelle has the natural ability to create forward momentum to build teams and get results. She inspires others to look within themselves and to challenge the status quo. She helps create high-performing environments. Michelle brings a diverse background: operations, employee development, and sales in the steel, hospitality, and consulting industries.
Outside of work, you will see her competitive side engaged in her daughter’s sports and ISU athletics. She loves life, her four-legged companions, and captures all the moments through her camera’s lens.
TRANSCRIPT
Andrea Fredrickson: Are you defining your culture by the values you’ve written down… or by the behaviors you actually allow every day? In this episode of The Leadership Hustle, we’re unpacking the difference between company values and culture, and why confusing the two can quietly undermine your organization. Hello, and welcome to The Leadership Hustle for executives whose companies are growing fast and need leaders who are ready. Welcome back. I’m Andrea Fredrickson.
Michelle Hill: And I am Michelle Hill.
Andrea Fredrickson: And we’re diving into a conversation that comes up in almost every organization we work with. We ask a simple question… tell us about your culture. And almost every time, what we get back are values.
And that’s where we pause. Because your values are not your culture. They might be what you aspire to. They might be what you hope people experience. But culture is something else entirely. It’s what actually happens day to day. It’s how people behave, how leaders respond, what gets rewarded, and what gets overlooked.
And when you start to look at it that way, it changes the conversation. Because now it’s not about what’s written on the wall. It’s about what’s happening in the room.